SUGAR–FREE chocolate sounds like the solution we’ve all been waiting for – but do they hit the sweet spot?

Brands including Mars and Cadbury claim they have created low-sugar and low-calorie versions of some of our favourite confectionery – the latest being Starburst, out last week.

Chocoholic Hayley Minn tested 'healthy' versions against the originals, comparing them on a variety of qualities

17

Chocoholic Hayley Minn tested ‘healthy’ versions against the originals, comparing them on a variety of qualitiesCredit: Paul Edwards

Chocoholic Hayley Minn tested the “healthy” versions against the originals, comparing them on price, taste, calories and size.

Galaxy (original) (£1.65 for 4, 42g)

Sugar: 23g - Calories: 229 - Taste: 5

17

Sugar: 23g – Calories: 229 – Taste: 5Credit: Paul Edwards

Galaxy Triple Treat (£1.75 for 4, 32g)

Sugar: 13g - Calories: 137 - Taste: 2

17

Sugar: 13g – Calories: 137 – Taste: 2Credit: Paul Edwards

I’M a big fan of Galaxy and would go as far to say it’s actually better than Dairy Milk.

So the thought of a healthy version was very exciting.

However, this fruit bar – made up of dates, raisins, peanut butter and chocolate – lacked the rich taste of the original.

I tested the best wines in a can from supermarkets - the winner was a Rosé
I tested own-brand bourbons - a cheap biscuit tastes just as good as McVitie's

Essentially a chewy fruit bar.

Double Decker (£1.59, 74g)

Sugar: 41g - Calories: 339 - Taste: 5

17

Sugar: 41g – Calories: 339 – Taste: 5Credit: Paul Edwards

Cadbury’s Delights (£1.35 for 5, 22g)

Sugar: 9.3g - Calories: 91 - Taste: 5

17

Sugar: 9.3g – Calories: 91 – Taste: 5Credit: Paul Edwards

YOU can’t really go wrong with Cadbury’s, and its new lower-calorie Delights range is just as good as you would expect.

The delicious nougat and salted caramel-flavoured snacks are like a Double Deckers – all that’s missing is the crunch.

Bounty (original) (£1.65 for 4,57g)

Sugar: 27.4g - Calories: 278 - Taste: 1

17

Sugar: 27.4g – Calories: 278 – Taste: 1Credit: Paul Edwards

Bounty Triple Treat (£1.75 for 4, 32g)

Sugar: 17g - Calories: 135 - Taste: 1

17

Sugar: 17g – Calories: 135 – Taste: 1Credit: Paul Edwards

I’M one of those people that finds eating a Bounty similar to a gross Bushtucker Trial.

Most read in Money

However, if you love the coconut flavour of the original bar, the Triple Treat tastes exactly like it.

It is the perfect replacement if you’re looking to cut calories.

Maryland Cookies (£0.75, 200g)

Sugar: 62g - Calories: 966 - Taste: 5

17

Sugar: 62g – Calories: 966 – Taste: 5Credit: Paul Edwards

The Skinny Cookie Co (£1, 200g)

Sugar: 0.6g - Calories: 868 - Taste: 1

17

Sugar: 0.6g – Calories: 868 – Taste: 1Credit: Paul Edwards

THE thought of Maryland Cookies with basically no sugar is eyebrow-raising, to say the least.

Unfortunately, those eyebrows should stay raised, as these Skinny Cookies are no match for the original.

You can tell there’s no sugar in them, as they’re dry, bitter and almost salty.

Snickers (original) (£1.65 for 4, 41.7g)

Sugar: 19g - Calories: 213 - Taste: 4

17

Sugar: 19g – Calories: 213 – Taste: 4Credit: Paul Edwards

Snickers Triple Treat (£1.75 for 4, 32g)

Sugar: 13g - Calories: 140 - Taste: 4

17

Sugar: 13g – Calories: 140 – Taste: 4Credit: Paul Edwards

SNICKERS are all about the peanut flavour, and the Triple Treats are covered in peanuts. Tick.

While the chocolate flavour was still missing, the peanuts masked the fruit in this one, so it was pretty good.

The sugar content is very similar to the original, but you can cut calories.

Percy Pigs (original) (£1.85, 170g)

Sugar: 100g - Calories: 581 - Taste: 4

17

Sugar: 100g – Calories: 581 – Taste: 4Credit: Paul Edwards

Reduced Sugar Percy Pigs (£1.85, 170g)

Sugar: 64g - Calories: 544 - Taste: 2

17

Sugar: 64g – Calories: 544 – Taste: 2Credit: Paul Edwards

IF you like Percy Pigs, stick with the originals.

The reduced sugar version tastes like cardboard, with no flavour whatsoever.

They’re nowhere near as sweet as the sugary ones, and yet they only contain 37 calories less than the originals.

Not worth it.

Mars (original) (£1.65 for 4, 39.4g)

Sugar: 24g - Calories: 177 - Taste: 5

17

Sugar: 24g – Calories: 177 – Taste: 5Credit: Paul Edwards

Mars Triple Treat (£1.75 for 4, 32g)

Sugar: 14g - Calories: 139 - Taste: 3

17

Sugar: 14g – Calories: 139 – Taste: 3Credit: Paul Edwards

MARS is known for its chocolatey, caramel taste.

Unfortunately, none of that really comes through in the Triple Treat, which consists of dates and raisins.

All I could taste was fruit, which wasn’t horrible, but it’s not a replacement for Mars.

Starburst (original) (£0.99, 152g)

Sugar: 88g - Calories: 619 - Taste: 5

17

Sugar: 88g – Calories: 619 – Taste: 5Credit: Paul Edwards

Starburst Fruit Squares (£1, 25g)

Sugar: 15g - Calories: 77 - Taste: 3

17

Sugar: 15g – Calories: 77 – Taste: 3Credit: Paul Edwards

LAUNCHED last week, Starburst Fruit Squares contain no added sugar.

Mums go wild for B&M's Easter baskets - they're super cute and an amazing price
Lidl is bringing back its bargain sell-out air fryer - but you have to be quick

On paper, that sounds very exciting, but if you take 100 grams of both versions, the tiny squares actually contain one gram more sugar than normal Starburst.

And there’s still a lot less flavour in them.

This post first appeared on thesun.co.uk

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

SMALL CAP MOVERS: Chipmaker Sondrel suffers as Arm enjoys Nasdaq debut

Given all the talk around Arm Holdings’ blockbuster debut on the Nasdaq,…

Thrill seekers should aim for Alternative Investment Market

Aim – the Alternative investment market – encompasses 765 companies. Sometimes described…

My friends say I’m a shopaholic but I’m 34, single and just like buying new things. How do I know if I have a shopping addiction? Money psychotherapist VICKY REYNAL replies

Dear Vicky,  I am a 34-year-old professional living in London. I make…

Thousands of Barclays customers to get up to £100 compensation after cashback error

BARCLAYS customers could get a compensation payout of up to around £100…